I Dream of Twilight modblog

If it was clearly incest though there’s still the question of why they had Big Mac and Marble interact the way they did. Marblemac shippers could at least have the argument that they were far enough in relation that it’s still legal. Or perhaps the Apples and Pies weren’t family… yet (Referring to how if Big Mac and Marble got married then they really would be family). You have to remember the episode where AJ and Pinkie tried to discover their family roots to see if they’re family it left it vague/open to interpretation pretty much.

Not that it matters that much anymore after this episode. But yeah. 

And I know a new writer wrote the episode as well. Just seemed like they were told mainly about Hearts and Hooves Day but was never told about the Season 5 episode with Pinkie’s family celebrating Hearth’s Warming with AJ’s family.

No, I don’t think Pinkie is flanderized much at all. Even in the early seasons Pinkie had her crazy moments that many who point the flanderization finger in later seasons often forget. Like it often seems that all they remember of Pinkie from the early seasons is how great the Smile song while ignoring that the rest of that same episode Pinkie gets as annoying as she sometimes is in later seasons.

I do think Season 4, even though it’s my favorite Season of the show thus far, did have the con of perhaps having the most inconsistent Pinkie from having perhaps her best episode of the series in Pinkie Pride but then followed up by not too long after one of her worst portrayals in Filli Vanilli. But I don’t blame the character for that, nor do I want to say I’m pointing fingers at the writers. Because heck Pinkie Pride and Filli Vanilli were actually written by the same exact writer (Amy Keating Rogers) but IMO she’s been better in Season 5 and 6. Too early to tell about Season 7, but the only iffy thing is part of the recent Maud episode where she was funny at first but she does kinda wear out her welcome about halfway through.

Still I enjoy Pinkie Pie alot and just like any member of the Mane 6 the show wouldn’t be the same without her.

Well, I certainly try to be fair. But I think I’d be lying if there weren’t characters I were critical of in the past. Probably most recently Fluttershy’s brother and farther back in the past, Flash Sentry. (Though that has decreased with each subsequent film… mostly because Flash’s role itself pretty much shrunk even smaller each time. Though I suppose he did have slightly more of a sub-plot then he did in Friendship Games but nothing plot important)

Also while I don’t hate Starlight, I’ve had my criticisms toward her too. But in regards to most of the main characters I have no problems with. Especially the Mane 6. ^^’

You and anyone else are free to ask my general opinion on individual characters.